Is the signal there?How sure do we need to be before we say “yes”?
An accessible primer for biologists · 2026
Select a section to jump ahead, continue with →, or use ↓ when an optional deep dive appears.
The same logic applies to laboratory assays, quality control, and clinical tests.
One framework
behavior ↔ neural responses
Landy describes SDT as the primary performance model for sensory experiments in audition, vision, and other modalities.
One scale: compare a neuron’s discriminability with the animal’s behavioral performance.
Landy, Fig. 11. Choice probability is an association with choice; by itself it does not prove that one neuron caused the decision.
Confidence-rating ROCs let the data test these competing descriptions.
Landy, Fig. 8. Curved empirical ROCs often favor continuous-evidence models, but the appropriate model should be checked rather than assumed.
Question: Does higher dopamine accompany more accurate perception—perhaps by changing sensitivity, criterion, or confidence?
“Correct” is not enough: we need to know which kind of correct—and which kind of error.
A useful detector has a high hit rate and a low false-alarm rate.
d′ and AUROC are related, not interchangeable: d′ is model-based; empirical AUROC can be nonparametric.
Landy, Fig. 1A.
Landy, Fig. 1C. Unequal priors or payoffs move the optimal criterion away from the midpoint.
Landy, Fig. 2.
Landy, Fig. 3.
c = 0 is unbiased only under the model’s equal-prior, equal-cost assumptions.
Optimal criterion
Accounts for both probability and value
for equal-variance Gaussian SDT and this deck’s criterion convention
Changing prevalence or value should shift c without changing sensory sensitivity d′.
Landy, Fig. 12. Meta-d′ is a model-based estimate and should be reported with its assumptions and uncertainty.
Landy, Fig. 4.
Area under the curve
0.5 = chance
1.0 = perfect
A criterion-free summary of ranking performance
AUROC = P(a random signal value ranks above a random noise value), with ties handled explicitly.
Landy, Fig. 10. Nonparametric does not mean assumption-free: representative sampling, independence, and uncertainty still matter.
Landy, Fig. 6. The √2 relation depends on the stated model and d′ definitions; real observers may also differ in sensitivity across intervals.
d′ = 1.68
The listener has meaningful—but imperfect—sensitivity to the tone.
c = 0
The listener has no estimated yes/no bias under the equal-variance model.
Landy, Fig. 9. Diagnose assumptions with multiple operating points; do not treat one hit/false-alarm pair as a full model check.
Every uncertain yes/no decision combinesevidence quality and a decision rule.
The first two sources and all original figures are included in text_and_figs/.
text_and_figs/